Overcoming the two walls
January 2024. A room full of suits with stiff collars were going to be listening to a testimony from a man with tattoos that crawled up his neck and across his face.
It was the United States Senate Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs and they were holding a hearing about the FEND OFF Fentanyl Act. The bill sought to address the escalating overdose deaths, which amounted to 75,000 people in 2022 alone, and among them were young children.
Jason DeFord was called in to talk about his experience with drug use and help the senators get a more intimate look at this problem.
But Jason, aka. Jelly Roll the musician, didn’t start with statistics and data, that would be avoiding the unignorable stains he’s had growing up surrounded by crime and drugs. Instead, he started by listing off all the reasons why they should NOT be listening to him.
He talked about his criminal past as a drug dealer, his forty-something arrests, his ten years in and out of jail and how he is probably the least credible person in that room.
Then he talked about how drugs have impacted him: “I could sit here and cry for days about the caskets I’ve carried of people I love dearly.” His personal experiences that brought him trouble, regret, and a heavy heart.
This was how Jelly Roll started his testimony and it worked.
This story is from the book Signal Gap and it was published this past week by my friend Henna Pryor, a workplace performance expert and award-winning author.
(I’ll be giving away a couple of books from my library this month 📚, see below for more details)
If you’ve ever had the experience where you’re not quite sure the person you are talking to is actually receiving your message, or you want to make sure your message lands, this issue is for you.
Today:
How to Get Someone Ready to Receive Your Message
Let’s get into it.
If your job requires your communication to land, this is for you.
Get your copy HERE.
⚡️ 60 SEC INFLUENCE
Always disarm before you deliver
Henna mentions in her book that the old world of TRUST first then VERIFY is over.
We are now in the age of VERIFY first, then TRUST. Why?
She breaks down 8 different reasons in her book, but the one that hits the hardest for me is this: polish got cheap — and suspicious.
It used to be that content and communications were judged by how polished they were. If it felt smooth, warm, and consistent, it was deemed trustworthy. But then with the introduction of AI, every piece of content can look good… and done in a matter of seconds.
And because of this explosion of polished things, we’ve become more suspicious of the things we see, and hear. What is real? What can I trust?
And so we’re all armed with a verification device and immediately start looking for signals that are hardest to fake.
So what’s the playbook?
Identify the wall (why is the audience skeptical?)
It could be a cognitive wall or an emotional wall and we have to identify and address them both.
Here are the questions to ask:
What have they been promised before that didn’t deliver?
What does this conversation really ask them to let go of?
What’s the “yeah, but” they’re already running in their heads?
Say it out loud (name it to tame it)
This is the secret to connection. Naming the exact thing people are thinking and feeling at the moment.
The cognitive wall comes down when you say what the other person is skeptical about. Henna’s example “You already have a growth mindset, so what do you need me for?”, for a talk about mindset and personal development.
The emotional wall comes down when you validate the feeling the audience is having or needs to have before becoming open to your message. Henna talks about how nurses will acknowledge your fear, how a CFO can acknowledge the disappointment after a difficult earnings call.
Your job is to help the audience lower their walls by acknowledging what the walls are.
Try these two moves in your next meeting, presentation, or tough conversation and let me know how it works out (you could win a free copy of the Signal Gap 👇🏽)
As promised, influence in 60 seconds.
📚 My Monthly Book Giveaway
If you used today’s influence playbook, hit reply and tell me what happened. Who were you trying to influence, what did you do, and what changed, or didn't?
I'll read every reply. Each month I'll send a book from my shelf to one or two people whose stories I want to hear more about (For U.S. only)
I will share the best ones in a future newsletter issue (unless you tell me not to!)
JUST HIT REPLY
🔎 DEEP DIVE
In the 60-second version, we covered one reason we’ve moved from “trust, then verify” to “verify, then trust”: polish got cheap.
Henna gives eight reasons in Signal Gap. Here are two more that explain why your audience walks in with their guard already up.
Reason 1: The comparison set got bigger
Think about how many hours you’ve spent watching real people talk on podcasts, YouTube, and Instagram. Unscripted. Unedited. Sometimes in tears.
All that watching has quietly trained your ear for what “real” sounds like. Henna calls it a “crowdsourced BS detector.”
Your audience has that same training. So when you stand up to speak, you’re being compared to every voice that ever felt honest to them. A rehearsed and scripted message has a hard time keeping up with that.
Reason 2: Your message travels without you
What you say in a meeting gets summarized in Slack, forwarded in an email, and screenshotted into a group chat, often before the day is over.
Researchers call this context collapse. Each new audience sees your words without the setup you gave them. The farther your message travels, the more chances someone reads it in the worst possible light.
There are many more reasons for people to doubt us, so we might as well start from a place of skepticism!
Wall cues to watch for in the room
Some walls you can predict before you walk in. Others only show up once you’re there. Here are five quiet signals Henna says to watch for:
It’s too quiet. Quiet can mean people are thinking. It can also mean they’ve decided to keep their thoughts to themselves.
It’s too polite. Real interest gets messy. People interrupt and build on each other. Careful, overly polite questions are often doubt in disguise.
Everyone nods at once. A nod usually just means “I hear you.” Real agreement shows up unevenly, at different moments and for different reasons.
One person does all the pushback. That person is often speaking for the room, and everyone else is watching how you respond. In Henna’s words, “The loud skeptic is the wall with a face.”
The words and the body don’t match. “I’m totally on board,” said with crossed arms. When the two disagree, believe the body.
When you spot one, pause and name it: “I’m sensing some hesitation. What’s the ‘yeah, but’ I should hear right now?”
The labor illusion: how to close the signal gap
If polish is easy to fake, what’s hard to fake?
Effort.
Harvard researchers Ryan Buell and Michael Norton tested this with a fake travel website. One group saw a standard progress bar while the site searched for flights. Another group watched the site check each airline one by one. The second group rated the service higher, even when they had to wait up to a full minute.
In another version, people booked the same trip on two sites and got identical results. One site gave them the results instantly. The other took 30 to 60 seconds and showed its work. Most people preferred the slower site.
This is the labor illusion. When we see the effort behind something, we value the result more, even when the result is exactly the same.
Here’s why it matters in the verification era. Your audience is scanning for signals that are hard to fake. Visible effort, real cost, and an honest process are all hard to fake. When you show the work, you give the skeptic something they can actually verify.
Think back to Jelly Roll. He walked into that Senate hearing and led with what it cost him to know what he knows: forty-some arrests, years in and out of jail, the caskets he carried. No study or slide deck could compete with that.
As a person of influence, your job is to make yourself easy to verify.
Application:
Before you share a recommendation, show the paths you ruled out. “We looked at three options. Here’s why we dropped two.”
Name the work behind the insight. “I talked to 14 customers before I wrote this.”
Share the messy middle: the first draft that flopped, or the data point that surprised you.
Name what the lesson cost you. A mistake you made can carry more credibility than a credential.
Only show real effort. If people catch you performing work you didn’t do, you’ll widen the very gap you’re trying to close.
Always disarm before you deliver. And when you deliver, let them see the work.
References
Pryor, H. (2026). The Signal Gap. Amazon link
Buell, R. W., & Norton, M. I. (2011). The labor illusion: How operational transparency increases perceived value. Management Science, 57(9), 1564–1579. https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.1110.1376
🔥 IN CASE YOU MISSED IT
10 ways your bio becomes part of the noise.
I see this every week. Smart people. Real expertise. Then a bio that sounds like everyone else's.
→ See the LinkedIn post (5,047 people have read this)
I’ll see you next Sunday!
Influence for good 🤘🏽,
Howie Chan
Creator of Influence Anyone
Subscribe to my YouTube channel
P.S. If you want more opportunities coming to you, save your seat in my FREE 2-hour workshop: How to build your professional brand.